Update: Kennecott Permit Application

An update of current events and anticipated timelines 1. The DNR has asked Kennecott to donate 120 acres to the State of Michigan to offset the use and lease of the 120 acres surrounding the Rock for their mine facilities. This offset would provide like public access that would be given up until the year 2042. Kennecott has responded that they would be willing to do that and selected 120 acres of their lands that abut the Yellow Dog Watershed Preserve on the Yellow Dog Plains.2. The DEQ has finished their internal investigation and find no malfeasance on the part of DEQ officials – only a lack of training and poor judgment. They will be doing the following in the ensuing months:- Retain the services of a third party geotechnical engineering expert to provide an independent evaluation of the crown pillar stability and potential hydrologic impacts – Reactivate the multidisciplinary mining team and prepare formal written procedures for the mining team to identify roles, responsibilities, and action steps for the application review process- Prepare written guidance to the mining team on maintenance of the permit application file with clear identification of the information to be made part of the public record and available on the DEQ Web site- Provide Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) training and written guidance for the entire mining team (and subsequently to all DEQ staff involved in responding to FOIA requests)- Offered to host a technical meeting with stakeholders (the opposition coalition)The DEQ has noted that it may be up to four months before the permit application is back on track and there is no word at what point the process will begin.3. Jim Paquette, a noted archeologist in Marquette County, submitted Eagle Rock as a formal archeological site with the State of Michigan who accepted the site noting that they would conduct an investigation in the spring. The State of Michigan then assigned Kennecott Minerals as their representative to investigate the site (!) – this after Kennecott archeological consultants found no evidence of archeological or historic influence at the Rock. Keweenaw Bay Indian Community will be monitoring the investigation.Thanks to Cynthia Pryor of The Yellow Dog Watershed Preserve for the concise update

The shadow of a mine: a metallic sulfide mining photo gallery

Copper Hill

Take a moment to view this slideshow of photos of the devastation wrought by the largest nickel mine in the world upon a landscape that was once not too different from the Yellow Dog.

More on Inco & Sudbury:

The Inco Mine at Sudbury, Ontario shows photos of the smelting facility, which is probably the single largest point-source for acid rain-causing emissions on the entire North American continent.

Rio Tinto looks to Sudbury for R&D explains how Kennecott parent company Rio Tinto is looking to Sudbury for mining knowledge.

Coaster Brook Trout Update

Efforts to have the Coaster Brook Trout listed as a federally endangered species could pay off by September.  Coaster Brook Trout are a population of Brookies that are much larger than average and spend most of their lives in the open waters of Lake Superior, only returning to rivers to spawn.  For more information read the article in the Mining Journal.

Also of interest is the Mining Journal article on the state of the Great Lakes and the role citizens and elected officials play in its future.   Read it and then write your legislators and tell them to get involved! 

Winners of the Video Challenge

The results are in from the public voting for the Save The Wild UP Video Challenge.

Drum Roll Please…

The Grand Prize Winner with 1907 votes is Josh Leo for his Video titled “Sulfide Mining Will Damage Michigan“. Prizes for the Grand Prize Winner include $2500 & a holiday package in the Huron Mountains of the Upper Peninsula.

The First Runner-Up with 1406 votes is Peter Schriemer for his video titled “Michigan’s Water and Wildlife“. Prizes for the First Runner-Up include a beautiful limited edition Coaster Brook Trout Print and a gift package from The Grocer’s Daughter Chocolate

The Second Runner-Up is Scott Lynch for his video titled “Kennecott Eagle Mine“. Prizes for the First Runner-Up include a beautiful limited edition Coaster Brook Trout Print and a gift package from The Grocer’s Daughter Chocolate.

Finalist Prize Package Every finalist will receive a prize package that includes a No Sulfide Mining T-Shirt (coming pretty soon!), Greg Brown’s new CD Yellow Dog (benefits the Yellow Dog Watershed Preserve) and a 1# bag of Higher Grounds Trading Co. coffee (fair-trade, shade grown, organic).

Save The Wild UP would like to give a heartfelt thanks to all the participants in this contest. Your creativitity and skills were enjoyed by thousands. Keep up the good work folks and get out and enjoy Michigan’s water!

We also want to thank:

The Water Festival

Earthwork Music

Grocer’s Daughter Chocolate

Higher Grounds Trading Co.

Absolute Michigan

Thunder Bay Inn

UPWaterFront.com

Michigan Waterways: Not For Sale

Private Mining Interests Try to Put a Price on Michigan’s Waterways
by Dick Huey

Salmon Trout RiverAmid the ancient forests and rocky outcroppings of the Upper Peninsula’s Yellow Dog Plains, the beautiful Salmon Trout River cuts a serpentine path as it alternates between flat water and cascading rapids on its way to the world’s premiere fresh water body—Lake Superior.

This river, set in pristine surroundings, is far removed from the hustle and bustle of Detroit and Lansing, but has nonetheless become a symbol of the best and worst of Michigan. The river is a testament to a state fiercely proud of its natural assets but increasingly neglectful of them in the face of budget crises and political combativeness.

While citizens discuss the economic future of the U.P. in terms of a clean environment, recreation and tourism, the Michigan Department of Environmental Quality (MDEQ) has revealed that its priorities lie elsewhere. The MDEQ is bumbling its way through a faulty review of a permit application to blast an acid-generating mine right beneath one of Lake Superior’s premiere tributaries, the Salmon Trout River. Despite an outcry from concerned citizens, the review of this proposed mine has taken place with the apparent blessing of a so-called ‘environmental Governor,’ who has consistently ducked and dodged the issue while the future of the Great Lakes hangs in the balance.

Read the rest of Not For Sale in Critical Moment magazine.

Governor Milliken: Join Voices, Protect Environment

From the Traverse City Record-Eagle and Detroit Free Press:

Let’s join voices to protect environment

No resource is more important to Michigan’s future than the Great Lakes. They literally surround us, leading to our identification as the “Great Lakes State.”

Any action that could threaten the quality of the Great Lakes must be approached with extreme caution, particularly by the State of Michigan. That is why all people who care about the future of this state and of the Great Lakes should be very concerned about a proposal now before the state Department of Environmental Quality to blast a nickel mine in the Upper Peninsula under the headwaters of the Salmon Trout River, one of Lake Superior’s primary tributaries.

The mine being proposed by the Kennecott Minerals Corp. would be much different from the iron ore mines that now exist and have existed in the U.P. for decades. It would involve blasting into underground sulfide ore deposits that contain nickel being sought by the mining company. Sulfide ores leach acid as soon as they come in contact with water or air.

Underground water seeping into the mine itself would create sulfuric acid, resulting in acid mine drainage of the equivalent of battery acid that would run off into rivers, contaminate groundwaters and end up in Lakes Superior and Michigan…

Read the rest of former Gov. William G. Milliken’s op-ed about sulfide mining in the Record-Eagle or in the Detroit Free Press (with photo but Freep only posts stories for a few weeks).

Investigation into processing of Eagle Project Mine Application appears a “whitewash”

On March 9, 2007, representatives of a number of environmental groups sent a letter to Michigan Department Environmental Quality Director Steven Chester regarding numerous grave concerns with MDEQ in connection with its review of the application filed by Kennecott Eagle Minerals Company. Click to read the letter to Steven Chester (PDF)

The report issued yesterday by a “independent” retired DNR official, Dr. Donald Inman of EcoLogic Ltd, regarding the investigation into the Processing of the Kennecott Eagle Minerals Company Eagle Project Mine Application appears to us to be an institutional whitewash. Click to read the MDEQ report (PDF)

Please read our letter, read the report and then YOU decide.

Analysis: Kennecott Eagle Minerals Company Proposal

An easy-to-read 6-page analysis of the Kennecott Permit Application from the National Wildlife Foundation

Analysis: Kennecott Eagle Minerals Company Proposal

NATIONAL WILDLIFE FEDERATION®
Great Lakes Natural Resource Center
213 West Liberty Street, Suite 200
Ann Arbor MI 48104-1398
734-769-3351
U.P. Contact: Michelle Halley, 906-361-0520


Fact Sheet: Kennecott U.P Sulfide Mining Proposal

A concise update on the Kennecot Permit Application from The National Wildlife Foundation

Fact Sheet: Kennecott U.P Sulfide Mining Proposal

NATIONAL WILDLIFE FEDERATION®
Great Lakes Natural Resource Center
213 West Liberty Street, Suite 200
Ann Arbor MI 48104-1398
734-769-3351
U.P. Contact: Michelle Halley, 906-361-0520