Last chance beckons

May 7, 2012
The Mining Journal

To the Journal editor:

Once again we learn why vision is so important when it comes to electing our government officials as we grimace at John Pepin’s story “Board rejects new draft of mine tax.”

The Marquette County Board rejected the third draft of Rep. Huuki’s legislation creating a non-ferrous mining operations severance tax. To the board we say big deal. You have no negotiating position anymore because you foolishly placed yourself squarely behind Rio Tinto’s proposed mining operations from the onset.

Where are we now? The mine is in its final stages of construction. We know that yet another alternative road proposal has been found unacceptable by two of the three federal agencies with oversight responsibilities.

And now we learn that the amount of money the local government will receive as Rio Tinto extracts billions of dollars worth ore from the earth beneath Marquette County is about to be slashed in half.

And there’s absolutely nothing these powerless local officials can do about it. Why would anyone think that Rio Tinto wouldn’t find a way out of building a road in the first place? Why would any state elected official, who have nothing but disdain for local governments, do anything but cut their money?

My plea to the Marquette County Board is simple. Go now to the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency and demand that they require a permit under the Clean Water Act for the Eagle mine water discharges. It’s your last chance at redemption and it is the law.

Jeffery Loman

Anchorage, AK

Clearing the air: Mine pro details Rio Tinto work

Guest op-ed

May 6, 2012
Kristen Mariuzza – Environmental Engineer and Permitting Manager, Rio Tinto Eagle Mine , The Mining Journal

The Mining Journal recently reported on Rio Tinto’s application to obtain a new air permit for the Eagle Mine. Although we are required to have this permit to operate, we do understand that it is not necessarily the permit that is important to you. It is the assurance that you, your family, our employees and the surrounding environment is not affected by our emissions.

Not only am I part of the Rio Tinto team responsible for environmental performance at Eagle, I was also born and raised here in the Upper Peninsula along with many of you. I want to ensure that we, along with our children and future generations, can enjoy what the U.P. has to offer just as we always have. My responsibility is to ensure Rio Tinto constructs and operates in a world class environmentally protective manner. It is a commitment that we all stand behind.

In 2007, the Michigan Department of Environmental Quality issued all permits required to build and operate the Eagle Mine. We are dedicated to complying with our permits and all other environmental regulations that affect our operation.

Nearly five years have passed since permits were originally issued. Since then, we have refined the design of the mine, and have identified measures that will reduce overall emissions from our operations.

Anytime there is a change in the quality, nature or quantity of air emissions, The MDEQ requires a new permit to be issued. This will consolidate all required air quality standards into a comprehensive document, reducing the potential for noncompliance and improving the ability of regulators to enforce them.

Following are the key modifications realized to further reduce our emissions, resulting in the requirement for a new air permit application.

Eagle was originally designed with three diesel-fuelled generators to provide on-site power for all operations. We have since provided electrical service from Alger Delta and have removed these generators from the design with only a single stand by generator remaining.

Converting to grid electricity will virtually eliminate generator use and the corresponding emissions from both the generators and the fuel trucks traveling to the property. In addition, a portion of the electricity will come from renewable sources, a practice that is fully supported and important to us.

Additional refinements to the site resulted in a reduction to the already low dust emissions expected. Ore handling on the surface will occur in an enclosed building rather than a three-sided structure. Dust inside the mine has been reduced through the improved, eliminated or relocated material handling operations. Rock storage piles and transfers at our backfill plant will now occur indoors. And finally, we moved the crushing activities originally planned for the mine to the Humboldt Mill.

For perspective, the particulate emissions, primarily dust, from Eagle that is listed in our permit application, amount to less than one half of a percent of Marquette County’s total industry emissions. In addition, emissions from our mine ventilation system will be equivalent to about 15 home wood burners.

Along with these design changes, the watering program we instituted on Marquette County Road 510/Triple A will reduce vehicle dust by approximately 90 percent compared to before operations. We encourage the use of carpools and provide a bus service to the mine for our employees and contractors.

As part of our commitment to environmental performance, we continually work to ensure compliance with regulatory standards, improve overall air emissions performance, be an industry best practice leader and remain engaged on air quality issues. We constantly review our emissions, look for ways to improve our performance and apply controls to minimize potential impacts from our operations.

We are confident that we can build, operate, and close Eagle responsibly with respect to both the environment and surrounding community. To supplement efforts required by regulators, Eagle will establish independent community monitoring of environmental performance at the Eagle Mine and Humboldt Mill.

This will be a partnership of local universities, the community, local Native American communities and Eagle working together. The purpose of the community-monitoring program is to enable unfiltered information about our performance. We also expect it will identify ways we can improve how we protect the environment.

On this topic and other matters we encourage you to go to our website at kennecotteagleminerals.com, visit our Information Center in downtown Marquette or call us at 486-6970.

Editor’s note: Kristen Mariuzza, is environmental engineer and permitting manager for the Eagle Mine project.

Rio Tinto Eagle Mine

504 Spruce Street

Ishpeming, MI 49849

T 906-486-1257

F 906-486-1053

Citizen Comment: CR 595 is nothing but a Kennecott Haul Road

Letter to the Mining Journal, 2-10-2012

To the Journal editor:

Marquette County Road 595 is being built because of the mine at Eagle Rock. If there were no mine, there would be no road. It is a road for the mine, a haul road.

Kennecott needs to step up to the plate and do what is right, and it is the Michigan Department of Environmental Quality’s job to make them follow the law. Continue reading

Witness: A personal account of local efforts to stop the Kennecott Eagle Project mine, by Jon Magnuson

Featured

Jogging down the stairs at Heathrow Airport to the underground train running to London, I carry in my overnight luggage a small container of wild rice, formal letters from the Keweenaw Bay Indian Community, and a document signed by a hundred faith leaders. My twenty-eight-year-old traveling companion, a local organic farmer, writer and activist, carries in his duffle bag—along with a newly purchased bargain-basement suit—a bottle of homemade maple syrup and seven packets of background information on a controversial proposed sulfide mining project near our homes in Northern Michigan.
It’s April 2008 and we travel with support from a number of Michigan-based nonprofit groups, arriving in England a couple of days early for the annual general meeting of one of the world’s largest multinational mining corporations. For twenty years Rio Tinto has been listed as a top choice for investors on the London Stock Exchange. The company also has been documented as being responsible for some of the worst environmental and human rights violations that exist in the modern mining industry. We’re here because they’ll soon be coming, dependent on final government permits, to our neighborhood.

Continue reading

The Most Important News Story of the Day/Millennium

Published on Monday, December 5, 2011 by CommonDreams.org

The Most Important News Story of the Day/Millennium

The most important piece of news yesterday, this week, this month, and this year was a new set of statistics released yesterday by the Global Carbon Project. It showed that carbon emissions from our planet had increased 5.9 percent between 2009 and 2010. In fact, it was arguably among the most important pieces of data in the last, oh, three centuries, since according to the New York Times it represented “almost certainly the largest absolute jump in any year since the Industrial Revolution.”

What it means, in climate terms, is that we’ve all but lost the battle to reduce the damage from global warming. The planet has already warmed about a degree Celsius; it’s clearly going to go well past two degrees. It means, in political terms, that the fossil fuel industry has delayed effective action for the 12 years since the Kyoto treaty was signed. It means, in diplomatic terms, that the endless talks underway in Durban should be more important than ever–they should be the focus of a planetary population desperate to figure out how

it’s going to survive the century.350.org

Continue reading

Rushing Mine Permits Puts Water At Risk

Opinion

October 31, 2011
by Eric Hanson

Wisconsinites have a deep affection for our pristine waters and a history of applying due diligence and reasonable prudence while questioning ill-conceived industrial projects that threaten that water. Think of the memorable citizens campaigns that blocked Exxon’s proposed mine on the Wolf River and Perrier’s plan for massive water withdrawals from the Mecan River watershed. 

Read post… http://www.jsonline.com/news/opinion/rushing-mine-permits-puts-water-at-risk-132959503.html

Eagle Rock: Economics versus spirit of place

By Jon Magnuson ,  The Mining Journal, 9-18-11

This past week The Mining Journal reported as a lead story Inghan County Judge Paula J. M Manderfield’s denial of a request for an injunction to stop Rio Tinto’s Kennecott Minerals Company from dynamiting Eagle Rock, the entrance to the proposed controversial sulfide mine in Powell Township.

Continue reading

Minnesota: Chamber, corporations pursue sulfide mining at cost of degrading Minnesota’s waters

By C.A. Arneson | Monday, Aug. 29, 2011

It was bad enough when the U.S. Supreme Court bestowed corporations with personhood – but under the guise of the title Chamber of Commerce, Minnesota now has its own corporative dictator. And Minnesota’s dictator wants sulfide mining at all costs – including the permanent degradation of Minnesota waters.

Continue reading

Minnesota Letter to the Editor: It’s crazy to damage our watershed

By: Bob Tammen, Duluth Budgeteer News

We care about our watershed. The Lake Superior Watershed Festival brought out hundreds of visitors to Lake Superior College Saturday to learn about threats to Lake Superior. One of the biggest future threats will be copper mining in the Duluth Complex of minerals. Mining promoters have an impressive array of talking points. Unfortunately, they don’t have a scientifically acceptable mining plan.

Polymet’s draft environmental impact statement got the lowest possible rating from the EPA, which issued a letter detailing the Continue reading

Statement of Protest Against Kennecott’s Eagle Mine And Support for Scott Rutherford’s Fast

Written by Jon W.  Magnuson

Lutheran pastor , Lutheran Campus Pastor (ELCA) at Northern Michigan University

Director, The Cedar Tree Institute

Deeply embedded in the best traditions of our democracy and carried by the heart of the great religions is a dream of a better, more beautiful world, the honoring of individual conscience, a respect for those who differ, and a promise to work together for a Common Good.

For the last seven years here in Marquette County we have been part of a Divine Drama.  An ongoing heated dispute around a decision whether or not to allow an international mining company, with one of worst records of environmental pollution and violation of human rights in the world, build a sulfide mine on the Yellow Dog Plains. Even now we hear their 100 ton double-axel trucks relentlessly pass through our city streets, haunting us day and night, as if making us believe that nothing can stop them.

When this is all over and done, it will all be about a choice. And whether or not we thought we had one. Well, we do.

I have a friend Kathy who spent two years in women’s prison in Virginia. She told me that the most important thing she learned there from another older wiser inmate is that even when one is incarcerated, one always has a choice: Whether to speak to speak or not to speak, whether to show kindness in difficult circumstances, to be generous with your few possessions, to live out a life of hope, compassion, justice.  I’ve talked to many citizens in our community who have expressed their opposition and disgust to Rio Tinto’s  sulfide mine.  But many of them feel that nothing can stop Kennecott.

I am here today to remind us we can choose to be victims or to engage and speak out for what we believe.  Back in 1978 Lois Gibbs, then a twenty-three year old housewife with no college education and two children back in Love Canal, discovered she was living with her neighbors on a toxic waste dump in New York State She organized her community and neighbors and forced one of the largest oil corporations in North America to clean the damage that was poisoning their families. Last October, she came and spoke to us here in Marquette. We stood up and cheered. She’s well known across North America fighting on behalf of poor communities, hotel workers, churches, kitchen workers, and immigrants.

In 2004, 100 leaders of ten faith traditions in Marquette, Baraga and Keweenaw Counties signed a petition that, based on studies of the impact of the proposed mine,

and standing in solidarity with of one of the oldest recognized Native communities in Northern Michigan (The Keweenaw Indian Community) formally stated their opposition

to Kennecott’s Eagle Rock mining operation.  That position remains unchanged.

There is a better way. Those gathering here today are lifting up a voice that our waters and land are not for sale to those who carry the threat of poisoning our children and grandchildren. Many of us in the faith community are committed to work with the Marquette Chamber of Commerce to renew their efforts to build a solid green economy. This is finally not about money and jobs. It’s about dedicating ourselves to a vision of a green economy where we work together to build new opportunities for employment, where our waters are protected and our children’s health is safeguarded. We can do that by saying “No” to Rio Tinto and it’s subsidiary company Kennecott.

This is a good fight. In the days and weeks ahead I will be personally supporting, along with a hundred other leaders of the faith community, Scott Rutherford’s hunger fast, a sacrament of protest to protect and to build a better and more beautiful, morally sound, and healthy vision for our grandchildren. Our prayers surround you Scott.

In the Judeo-Christian tradition, there is an account in Genesis of God giving his Chosen People a list of Commandments. Among them it is written,  “Thou shalt not steal.”  At the end of that account, Moses words ring out, but this time now for us all across the lands of Northern Michigan, through our homes, across the Great Lake of Superior, over our gardens, our schoolyards, over our forests and streams,

“So I call heaven and earth to witness against you this day, that I have set before you life and death, blessing and curse Therefore choose life that you may dwell in this sacred land, loving the Lord your God for the length of your days.”

This is that moment. Our day. Our time.

7/9/11